Back to Blog
Comparisons 2026-11-16 Newton Baby: #1 Rated Baby Crib Mattress 0 views

Extra Crib Mattress Covers: Essential vs Waterproof Picks

Extra Crib Mattress Covers: Essential vs Waterproof Picks

Compare Newton's Extra Essential and Extra Waterproof crib mattress covers by fabric, fit, washing, and price so you can choose the right spare for your mattress.

The two covers serve different mattresses

Newton sells two extra crib mattress covers, but they are not interchangeable with each other. The Extra Essential Crib Mattress Cover is made for the core of the Essential Crib Mattress in Standard size. The Extra Waterproof Crib Mattress Cover is made for the core of the Waterproof Crib Mattress in Standard size. Before you compare fabric or price, confirm which mattress you own. A spare cover only helps if it fits the mattress it was designed for.

Both covers are Standard size and both use a full zipper to remove and replace the cover. The difference is in the layers, the waterproofing, and the wash routine.

Fit and dimensions at a glance

  • Extra Essential Crib Mattress Cover: Standard dimensions: 52" x 28" x 4"; single layer of breathe-thru spacer fabric with a natural viscose lining attached. This is the fit reference for the Essential Crib Mattress core, so you can check your mattress before buying a spare.
    Extra Essential Crib Mattress Cover
    Extra Essential Crib Mattress Cover
  • Extra Waterproof Crib Mattress Cover: Standard dimensions: 52" x 28" x 5.5"; dual-layer breathe-thru spacer fabric quilted together, with a TPU waterproof liner on the toddler side of the cover. The Waterproof cover is thicker and adds a TPU barrier, which explains its different fit and price.
    Extra Waterproof Crib Mattress Cover
    Extra Waterproof Crib Mattress Cover

Fabric and waterproofing: what changes for your baby

The Essential cover is a single breathable layer with a viscose lining. The Waterproof cover is a quilted dual layer with a TPU waterproof liner on the toddler side. That liner is the main functional difference: it helps protect during potty training stages, while the Essential cover is a soft breathable layer without that barrier.

  • Extra Essential Crib Mattress Cover: Single-layer breathe-thru spacer fabric with a natural viscose lining. Soft and breathable, designed to replace the Essential Crib Mattress cover when accidents happen.
  • Extra Waterproof Crib Mattress Cover: Dual-layer quilted cover with a TPU waterproof liner on the toddler side. Adds waterproof protection while remaining breathable.

Washing and drying: the routines are not the same

Both covers can be machine washed, but the Waterproof cover has an inner encasement that needs different care. For the Essential cover, Newton lists machine wash cold, alone, on delicate cycle; do not bleach; tumble dry thoroughly on low; zip the cover closed before washing. To refresh, you can add 1/2 cup baking soda to the wash. Replace the cover if damaged and contact Customer Care for assistance.

For the Waterproof cover, the outer cover follows the same machine wash cold, alone, delicate cycle and tumble dry low instructions. The inner encasement is different: clean it only if soiled, hand wash or spot clean with cool water as needed, and do not hang dry. Newton notes the viscose material may develop an odor if it remains damp, so drying thoroughly matters. Baking soda can be added while handwashing the encasement to refresh it.

Price and collection details

  • Extra Essential Crib Mattress Cover: Catalog price USD 44.09 (comparison price USD 69.99). Part of the Newton Essentials collection, excluded from sitewide sales and individual promotional offers. The Essential spare is the lower-cost option, but it is excluded from promotions, so plan your purchase accordingly.
  • Extra Waterproof Crib Mattress Cover: Catalog price USD 60.99 (comparison price USD 99.99). The Waterproof spare costs more because of its dual-layer quilted construction and TPU liner.

How many extra crib mattress covers should you buy?

The right number depends on how often you wash and whether you want a spare ready during night accidents. Newton describes these as backup covers for when the cover is soiled and needs to be laundered. A practical approach is one cover on the mattress and one clean spare, so you are not washing and drying under pressure.

  • One spare for the mattress you own: If you already have an Essential Crib Mattress, the Extra Essential cover gives you a same-fabric replacement. If you have a Waterproof Crib Mattress, the Extra Waterproof cover matches that mattress.
  • A second spare if laundry access is limited: The Waterproof cover's inner encasement requires hand washing or spot cleaning and must not be hang dried, which can slow turnover. A second Waterproof cover may help if you rely on machine washing the outer cover.

Sheets and everyday use

Newton notes that while the covers are soft, washable, and breathe-thru, most parents use a Newton Organic Cotton Sheet over the mattress cover. The covers are not described as a replacement for a sheet. Washing the cover before first use is optional. For the Waterproof cover, the TPU liner is on the toddler side, so placement matters when you put the cover back on the mattress core.

What the supplied information does not confirm

The supplied records do not include safety ratings, load limits, or assembly steps beyond zipping the cover on and off. They also do not state a recommended number of covers or a washing frequency. Use the care instructions above and your own laundry routine to decide. If a cover is damaged, Newton directs you to replace it and contact Customer Care for assistance.

Related Articles

Customer Service
Home
Products
Cart
Profile